Designed for talent pros and hiring teams

Topgrading Interview

Are you tired of sifting through stacks of resumes and conducting lackluster job interviews? Look no further than the Topgrading Interview method. Developed by Brad Smart, this method aims to identify the "A players" - the top performers in their field - and bring them on board to drive company success. In this blog post, we will dive into the specifics of the Topgrading Interview method and how it can revolutionize your hiring process. From understanding the criteria for an "A player" to conducting the interview itself, we'll cover it all. So, grab a pen and a notebook, and let's get started.

5.0

Add an AI assistant to your interviews

Start with 5 interviews for free

Already have an account?

Log in

Introduction

Are you tired of sifting through stacks of resumes and conducting lackluster job interviews? Look no further than the Topgrading Interview method. Developed by Brad Smart, this method aims to identify the "A players" - the top performers in their field - and bring them on board to drive company success.

In this blog post, we will dive into the specifics of the Topgrading Interview method and how it can revolutionize your hiring process. From understanding the criteria for an "A player" to conducting the interview itself, we'll cover it all. So, grab a pen and a notebook, and let's get started.

What is the Topgrading Interview method?

The Topgrading Interview method is a comprehensive approach to hiring that seeks to identify the top performers in a given field. It was developed by Brad Smart, CEO of Topgrading, Inc. and author of the book "Topgrading: How Leading Companies Win by Hiring, Coaching, and Keeping the Best People."

The method involves a series of interviews, both with the candidate and with their references, as well as a thorough review of their work history. The goal is to gain a comprehensive understanding of the candidate's strengths, weaknesses, and overall fit for the role and company.

The Criteria for an "A Player"

According to Smart, an "A player" is someone who consistently performs in the top 10% of their field. These individuals are not only skilled in their current role, but also have the potential for growth and advancement within the company.

The Topgrading Interview method assesses candidates against several criteria to determine if they fit the profile of an "A player." These include:

  • Proven track record of success in their current and past roles

  • Strong work ethic and drive to succeed

  • Positive attitude and ability to work well with others

  • Clear career goals and aspirations

  • Willingness to continuously learn and improve

The Interview Process

The Topgrading Interview process is divided into three parts: the phone screen, the in-person interview, and the reference check.

The phone screen is a brief conversation to assess the candidate's qualifications and fit for the role. If the candidate passes this step, they move on to the in-person interview.

The in-person interview is a comprehensive and in-depth conversation, lasting anywhere from 2-4 hours. The interviewer will ask a series of behavioral-based questions to gain insight into the candidate's past performance and potential for success in the role.

Finally, the candidate's references will be checked to gain a more well-rounded understanding of their performance and work style.

Behavioral-Based Questions

One of the key components of the Topgrading Interview method is the use of behavioral-based questions. These questions aim to gain insight into the candidate's past performance and potential for success in the role.

Examples of behavioral-based questions include:

  • Can you tell me about a time when you had to make a difficult decision?

  • Can you give an example of a project you led and the outcome?

  • How do you handle conflicts with coworkers or supervisors?

The Past Performance Review (PPR)

The PPR is a detailed examination of the candidate's work history, including responsibilities, accomplishments, and challenges. The PPR is meant to provide a clear picture of the candidate's abilities and to identify any red flags.

The Importance of Reference Checks

Reference checks are an essential part of the Topgrading Interview method. They provide a more well-rounded understanding of the candidate's performance and work style, and can confirm or refute information provided during the interview.

It's important to note that reference checks should be conducted with individuals who have directly worked with the candidate in a supervisory capacity. This will provide the most accurate and valuable information.

The Role of the Interviewer

The success of the Topgrading Interview method relies heavily on the interviewer's ability to effectively conduct the interview and assess the candidate's qualifications and fit for the role.

The interviewer should be well-versed in the criteria for an "A player" and the behavioral-based questions to be asked. They should also be able to effectively evaluate the candidate's responses and assess their potential for success within the company.

Advantages of the Topgrading Interview Method

There are several advantages to using the Topgrading Interview method in your hiring process. These include:

  • Improved ability to identify top performers and "A players"

  • Greater understanding of the candidate's strengths, weaknesses, and overall fit for the role and company

  • Reduced turnover and improved retention of top performers

  • Increased productivity and company success

Potential Drawbacks

As with any hiring method, there are potential drawbacks to the Topgrading Interview method. These include:

  • Time-consuming and resource-intensive process

  • Dependence on the interviewer's ability to effectively conduct the interview

  • Potential for bias in the reference check process

  • May not be suitable for all industries and roles

Implementing the Topgrading Interview Method

To successfully implement the Topgrading Interview method in your hiring process, it's important to have buy-in from leadership and HR. This includes ensuring that the necessary resources, such as time and budget, are allocated for the process.

It's also important to provide training for interviewers on the criteria for an "A player" and the behavioral-based questions to be asked. Regular evaluations and adjustments to the process should also be made to ensure its effectiveness.

Conclusion

The Topgrading Interview method is a comprehensive and effective approach to hiring top performers and "A players." By assessing candidates against specific criteria and gaining a well-rounded understanding of their qualifications and fit for the role and company, companies can improve their chances of hiring and retaining top talent.

However, it is important to note that this method is not suitable for all industries and roles, and its success heavily relies on the interviewer's ability to effectively conduct the interview and reference check. With the right resources and training, the Topgrading Interview method can be a game-changer for your hiring process.

How Hume Can Help

Hume is an interview intelligence platform that can help streamline and enhance the Topgrading Interview method. With its ability to record, transcribe, and summarize interviews, teams can unlock the full potential of their interviews and make data-driven decisions.

Some specific ways that Hume can help include:

  • Recording and transcribing interviews: This allows teams to review and analyze the interview at a later time and gain a deeper understanding of the candidate's qualifications and fit for the role.

  • Summarizing interviews: With the ability to automatically summarize interviews, teams can quickly and easily review key points and make data-driven decisions.

  • Improving interviewers' performance: With access to objective data and insights, interviewers can receive feedback and training to improve their performance and better identify "A players."

Overall, Hume can be a valuable tool for teams implementing the Topgrading Interview method. It can help to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the process and provide valuable insights for making data-driven hiring decisions.

Join the talent teams loving Aspect.

Join the talent teams loving Aspect.

Imagine transforming every interview into a strategic advantage. Dive deep into every conversation, free from the distraction of note-taking. This isn't just wishful thinking – with Aspect, it's how you'll redefine your hiring process.